Just as love begins to blossom, Caleb Yoder must stop courting Nellie Fisher. His Old Order dad forbids it. Although nothing can quench Caleb's devotion to Nellie, thoughts of losing his promised 100 acres of prime farmland give him pause. Nellie, too, is torn. Despite wanting to marry Caleb, she can't deny the allure of her family's New Order faith. But how can they pursue true love without alienating their families?